Professional reviewers work from checklists so that every ship is judged the same way. You can borrow the approach. Use these lists when reading expert cruise reviews, when touring a ship on embarkation day, or when writing notes for your own future reference. The questions change with the type of ship, because a 6,000-guest resort ship and a 100-guest expedition vessel are trying to do different things.
Every Ship
- Cabin: size, storage, bed comfort, soundproofing, bathroom and shower, balcony privacy.
- Dining: variety, quality in the included restaurants, what costs extra, waits at peak times.
- Service: crew attitude, how problems are handled, staffing in busy areas.
- Public spaces: crowding on sea days, quiet areas, condition and cleanliness.
- Embarkation and disembarkation: how smooth, how long, how clearly communicated.
By Ship Size and Type
| Ship type | What experts look at closely |
|---|---|
| Large resort ships | Crowd flow, reservation systems for shows and activities, kids’ clubs, value of included dining, noise near venues |
| Mid-size premium ships | Cuisine and specialty dining, enrichment, balance of quiet and lively spaces, port-intensive itineraries |
| Small luxury ships | Personal service, space per guest, inclusions, wine and dining standards, suite quality |
| Expedition ships | Expedition team, Zodiac operations, time ashore, ice class, lectures, mudroom and gear |
| River ships | Cabin layout in a narrow hull, included excursions, docking locations, sun deck use |
Turning Notes Into a Decision
Mark each item as a must-have, a nice-to-have or irrelevant to you before you start reading reviews. Then score ships only on your must-haves. This is exactly how a good advisor narrows a list, and it stops a single spectacular feature from distracting you from the basics that will shape every day of your cruise.
Check the layout around any cabin you are considering on Cruise Ship Deck Plans; many low review scores for cabins trace back to location rather than the cabin itself.
Your Own Embarkation-Day Review
Professional reviewers walk the whole ship early, before it fills. You can do the same on embarkation day, when many public areas are quiet. Walk from your cabin to the main dining room, the pool deck and the theater, and note how long each takes. Look at the quiet spaces you might use on a sea day. Check the noise around your cabin at night. Write it down; next time you compare ships, your own notes will be the most relevant review you can read.
A simple scoring habit helps: after each cruise, rate the ship from one to five on the five items in the “every ship” list above, add one sentence on what you would change, and note the cabin number and whether you would book it again. Over a few voyages, those notes become your personal ratings guide, built on exactly the criteria that matter to you, and they make every conversation with an advisor faster and more precise.
Send Us Your Must-Haves
Our cruise advisors at Mister Cruise will match your checklist with the ships that fit it best.
Ask a Cruise Expert