Cruise Ship Ratings, the Expert Way
Who rates cruise ships, what they measure, and how to use their scores.
Ask a Cruise ExpertCruise ship ratings come from very different places: a veteran guidebook author with a points system, a news organization blending editors’ judgments with traveler scores, public health inspectors with a clipboard, and thousands of passengers with a five-star button. This site focuses on the professional side — the experts and their methods — so you can tell what a rating measures before you let it decide your vacation.
Ratings are most useful when you know three things: who produced them, what they measured, and when. A score from a guide that judges cuisine and service in fine detail can be perfect for choosing a luxury ship and nearly useless for a family looking for waterslides. A traveler rating from last month may matter more than an expert visit from three years ago. And a health inspection score tells you about sanitation on one day, not about the entertainment.
The Main Kinds of Cruise Ship Ratings
| Source | Who does the rating | Best used for |
|---|---|---|
| Expert guidebook (Douglas Ward’s Berlitz guide, now Insight Guides) | One author and team, fixed criteria, points out of 2,000 | Comparing ship quality, food and service across the whole industry |
| Publication rankings (for example U.S. News Best Cruise Lines) | Editors’ evaluations combined with traveler ratings and health results | Shortlisting lines by trip type: families, couples, value, luxury |
| Editorial ship reviews (Cruise Critic editors, travel magazines) | Staff writers who sail and report | Understanding a ship’s style, layout and atmosphere |
| Official health inspections (CDC Vessel Sanitation Program) | Government inspectors, 100-point scale | Checking sanitation records on ships calling at U.S. ports |
| Consumer reviews and member ratings | Passengers | Recent, real-life detail on cabins, crowds and service |
How to Use Expert Ratings Well
- Start with your trip type. Decide whether you care most about food, quiet, kids’ facilities, nightlife or price.
- Pick the rating built for that. A luxury-weighted score for a gourmet trip; a family category for a family trip.
- Check the date. Ships are refurbished, menus change and new ships arrive every year.
- Cross-check. Compare an expert score with recent cruise ship ratings and reviews from passengers.
- Ask someone who books them. Advisors hear what clients say after every sailing.
Our pages walk through each source: who the cruise experts are, the Berlitz cruise guide and its 2,000-point scale, the cruise ship ratings for 2026 from U.S. News, health inspection scores and an expert-style checklist you can use yourself. For the consumer side — where passenger reviews live and how to spot fake ones — our sister site Cruising Reviews has the detail, and Cruise Awards explains the award programs.
Experts sail too
Professional reviewers judge the same decks, cabins and dining rooms you will, but with a fixed checklist.
Who the experts are →
The guidebook view
One author’s consistent scoring across hundreds of ships remains a rare resource.
The Berlitz guide →
What gets scored
Food, service, cabins and the overall experience carry most of the weight in expert scoring.
The checklist →Expert Cruise Reviews is part of the Smart Traveler network, led by Mister Cruise. He has sold travel since 1972 and worked full-time in the industry since 1977. He has sold or originated more than $500 million in cruises and has trained more than 500 travel agents.
Ratings are a starting point. Our cruise advisors at Mister Cruise add what clients tell us after they sail — and book everything for you, not a call center. Meet Mister Cruise →
Frequently Asked Questions
Who gives the most reliable cruise ship ratings?
No single source is perfect. Long-running expert guides use consistent criteria across hundreds of ships; publications such as U.S. News combine expert and traveler input; official health inspections measure one thing very precisely. Reading two or three different kinds of rating gives the most reliable picture.
Are expert cruise reviews paid for by the cruise lines?
Reputable reviewers either pay their own way or disclose when a line has hosted them. In the United States, the FTC’s endorsement rules expect reviewers to disclose material connections such as free cruises. Look for that disclosure.
Why do two experts rate the same ship so differently?
They measure different things. One may weight food and service heavily, another value for money or family facilities. Check what each rating is designed to measure before comparing the numbers.
Do you rate cruise ships yourselves?
No. We explain how the established rating systems work so you can use them well. For advice on a specific ship, our cruise advisors at Mister Cruise will share what they know from clients and ship visits.
More Cruise Sites From Our Network
Get an Expert Opinion on Your Ship
Tell our cruise advisors at Mister Cruise which ships you are comparing. We will explain the differences that ratings miss — free.
Ask a Cruise Expert